|
|
|
Plenary Lecture
'Clean' Energy and Poor People: Ecological Impacts of Hydroelectric Dams on
Fish and Fishermen
in the Amazon Rainforest

Professor Renato A. M. Silvano
Co-Authors: Anastacio A. Juras, Alpina Begossi
Department of Ecology
University Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS)
CP 15007, 91501-970, Porto Alegre, RS
BRAZIL
E-mail: renato.silvano@ufrgs.br
Abstract:
Hydroelectric power generated from man-made reservoirs is sometimes regarded
as a ‘clean' or environmental friendly energetic source, due to the lack of
pollution mainly from liquid and solid effluents. However, several
researchers have been claiming that such form of energy production may
sometimes generate intense and irreversible environmental impacts,
especially when large reservoirs are built in natural tropical regions,
which usually have a rich biodiversity of aquatic and terrestrial organisms.
Our major goal is to provide a brief review of one dimension of such
reservoirs' impacts in a large tropical region: the ecological effects of
large dams and reservoirs to fish and fisheries in the Brazilian Amazon
rainforest. We also analyzed in detail the ecological effect of Tucurui
reservoir on fish and fisheries of the Lower Tocantins River, as a study
case. Amazon people rely mostly and sometimes solely on fisheries as their
main source of animal protein and cash income. Some of the large reservoirs
may had potentially affected this economic activity mainly in the region
downstream from the dam, due to changes in the flooding regime, retention of
nutrients in the reservoir and blockage of reproductive migrations of
economically important fishes. Such effects may generate or enhance poverty
in short time, social conflicts and economic isolation of riverside fishing
communities, but these problems are less understood than direct changes on
fish communities. In a recent survey (2006-2008) in the Lower Tocantins
River, interviewed fishers from eight communities mentioned impacts of the
Tucurui reservoir, such as decrease in the abundance of fish. Nevertheless,
these fishers still maintain a frequent fishing activity, which indicates
that at least some commercial fishes have been able to cope with the
reservoir effects, some may have even benefited from this, although the
composition of fish catches changed compared to pre-impoundment period
(before 1985). A possible factor allowing the persistence of fishes and
fisheries in this region may be the floodplain with several lakes, which are
important fish spawning sites, according to fishers and biological data.
This survey also highlights that effects of a large dam may extend far
beyond the reservoir itself, and that fishers have a good deal of knowledge
about their aquatic environments and changes to it. Also, the potential
effects of alleged ‘less impacting' energy production on people and fish
should be better acknowledged in political and economic decisions regarding
energy issues.
* Project supported and financed by P&D Eletronorte, N? Contract:
4500057477; Project (ANEEL): 018/2005.
Brief Biography of the Speaker:
I have been doing research dealing with artisanal fisheries, fish ecology
and ethnobiology since 1994, participating in about 11 research projects
conducted in marine, estuarine and freshwater environments in the southeast
and northeast Brazilian coasts, as well as the Brazilian Amazon. Currently,
I am a research and professor in the department of Ecology of the Federal
University of Rio Grande do Sul in Porto Alegre, Brazil. I published about
16 peer-reviewed articles in journals such as Environmental Biology of
Fishes, Fisheries Research, Ecological Economics, Hydrobiologia and Aquatic
Conservation. I presented either orally or as poster more than 30 abstracts
in Brazilian and international scientific meetings.
I have been also reviewing manuscripts to Brazilian and international
scientific Journals, such as Environmental Biology of Fishes, Fisheries
Research, Human Ecology, Environmental Management and Journal of
Ethnobiology.
Since December 2007, I am an official advisor of the International
Foundation for Science (IFS) (Sweden), evaluating research projects for
funding.
|
|
|